Humanoid robot washing dishes at a kitchen sink in evening light, no people, logos or readable text
AI-generated image

Tesla

Musk says every humanoid demo you have seen is staged, and promises Optimus will do an unscripted one within two months

Elon Musk has a problem with other companies' robot videos. "Elon Musk says Tesla might give an unscripted Optimus demo in a month or two," XRoboHub posted on X on Thursday. "Asked when Optimus could take out the trash and do the dishes, he put that at 12 to 18 months."

Musk was speaking remotely from Shenzhen to the TomorrowX Summit in Austin. According to a transcript of the session, he said Tesla will show Optimus "when we can do a demo that we feel that the demo is authentic and not just staged or pre-programmed. Because really, the humanoid robot demos that you see are staged and pre-programmed. They are not real."

The apple test

His example was simple. Current robots, he said, can be told to "go pick up an apple," but if you move the table "it won't be able to pick up the apple anymore." Tesla's demo "might be, I don't know, in a month or two," he said, and should show what Optimus can actually do.

He also cited a test from programmer John Carmack: hand a robot a boxed toy remote-control car and see if it can unbox it, unscrew the battery cover, fit the batteries, screw the lid back on and drive it. "There's no robot in the world that can do that," Musk said.

Dishes in 12 to 18 months

Asked about household chores, Musk described scraping a dirty plate, washing it, drying it and putting it away. "There's no humanoid robot that can do that at all," he said. "But I think Optimus will be able to do it in 12 to 18 months." The CyberRobooo account picked out his comment that Optimus will start in heavy industry: mining and refining ore, which Musk tied to national security.

Read with care

Musk's timelines for Tesla products have often slipped, and none of these dates are commitments. The 12-to-18-month figure is for a capability, not for sales. Tesla has separately pointed to Optimus deliveries from late 2027, as covered in our deliveries story, and Musk has floated renting rather than selling the robot, as reported in our rent-not-sell story.

Whether Tesla's own demo meets the standard Musk set for everyone else is the thing to watch.

← All news